Claire’s PTSD storyline in episode 2.09 of Outlander deviates from Diana Gabaldon’s written words, running the ever-standing risk of alienating book readers; this change was no exception as some voices expressed concern over a depiction of Claire as weakened or different. Consider that in the opening scene of the very first episode of the Starz adaptation of Outlander, Ron D Moore chose to show us the fierce and determined combat nurse that is Claire Randall, as she bears that burden of simply doing it right. This is her identity laid out for us at the outset. Knowing this, Claire’s PTSD storyline cannot be an unwanted story addition; in fact, it is implicit to this writer and nurse that Claire’s war experiences must impact her in ways that run deep. To never examine them would seem a disservice to Claire as a character immersed in the blood and horror of a world war.
Claire’s PTSD surfaces as the Highlanders prepare for war, and her World War II memories suddenly emerge. A meal, casual introductions, and cultural comparisons set the stage for a short-lived relationship with two American soldiers. En route with the men to seek out their unit, a German tank attack leaves one soldier gravely injured. Claire’s instinct is to leave her hiding spot and help him, but she is urged to stay put to maintain her safety. The brutal and swift death that follows leaves Claire powerlessness to help either man, and she is left frightened and alone until discovered the next morning terrified and in shock.
PTSD in 18th century Claire echoes many modern-day presentations. She is irritable and withdrawn, with volatile outbursts brought on by seemingly unrelated events. Fergus playing shinty, even Angus’ muddy feet bring Claire’s uncontrollable memories to light. She lashes out at these people that she cares about, showing an unexpected side of her personality.
Jamie is also on high alert; as a Highlander and warrior, he seeks warning and safety, and as Claire’s husband, he senses Claire’s moods and needs as instinctively as his actions as a warrior. Broken by way of the trauma inflicted on him by Jack Randall, his recovery hinged on Claire’s determination and love. As his emotional integrity slowly heals, he shifts to Claire’s as hers gives way. Burdened with the knowledge that the impending Battle of Culloden stands to follow the true course of history, Claire’s fears surface. In a beautifully realized scene, we finally see the full context of the snip of the season 2 “Dear God” trailer, as Claire flinches painfully at the sound of each musket shot. Despite watching the trailer an infinite number of times, it gels in a heartbreaking way now.
Perhaps for Claire, the broad brush of British stoicism combined with her pragmatism helped subvert the horrors of war to a subconscious place; maybe that place is akin to Jamie’s description of himself hiding beneath the blade of grass which could not shield his deepest and most private sense of self.
Today, one of the first-line treatments for PTSD includes cognitive “talk” therapy, which is all that is available to Claire as the Battle of Culloden looms. Guilt and a sense of helplessness to save these two soldiers who are relative strangers to Claire blooms into a more stunning reality of losing those that she has grown to love. Jamie is intelligent enough and loving enough to offer the gift of listening and reflection to help move Claire’s healing forward.
What are your thoughts on this WW II storyline for Claire?
Does it add value to the Outlander story?
Completely appropriate to add this to the story. One of the best "additions" that Ron Moore has made. Makes total sense and was very interesting to see more of Claire's "former life." I, too, liked how Jamie became the care giver. Role reversal. What a true partnership is really all about. Great piece, Teddie!
I think over the course of the series of books, there has been some hints of Claire's PTSD but it wasn't overly fleshed out. I thought it was a very appropriate addition to the shows in the run-up to a war. So much more nuanced to not have it just the typical rah-rah gun-ho pre-war sentiment (Dougal) and include the downsides, especially as Claire had an experience that none of the rest had (except Jamie). So well done. The little looks and touches between Jamie and Claire clearly depict their bond more than just necked romantic scenes would.
Thank you for such an insightful evaluation of this episode, PTSD and specifically nursing. My brother is a burns unit nurse and was diagnosed with PTSD late last year. I am going to share this with him.
Anne, thank you for reading and commenting! Claire's war experiences could not be packaged into that one introductory scene in S1 without marginalizing that aspect of her life. I loved the addition as well!!
Linda, thanks for your response. It was indeed a wonderful inclusion to delve deeper into Claire' psyche. I felt I was right there with Claire as the flashbacks came to the forefront. For all the book purists out there, I see this as a great example of how the adaptation takes the story to some great places.
Thank you, woodowl, and sorry to hear of your brother's experience. Burns are one of the toughest areas of nursing; I don't think I myself have what it takes to work in that specialty area. There is a lot of help out there for people with PTSD. Best wishes for your brother's recovery.
Did you know that you can create short links with AdFly and get dollars from every click on your short links.