For many fans Outlander Season 2 was the season to forget. But now that we’ve seen Season 3, here are 15 reasons to rewatch Outlander Season 2.
When Outlander Season 2 ended, I was worried. Yes the season was good, but it was not as great as Season 1. Not only did we have to live through #SexDroughtlander but the writers opted to pit Jamie and Claire against each other, a change from the book that I thought was misdirected. (And I say this in full agreement that it’s okay for the book and TV show to differ. I just thought that was a poor choice.)
And so, unlike Season 1, where the remote control practically auto-corrected to Outlander by itself, I didn’t rewatch Season 2 at all except for the “Faith” episode. Instead I spent that Droughtlander worrying that Matt B. Roberts et al had lost their Outlander compass and that Season 1 was going to turn out to have been the series’ acme.
Season 3, though, brought us back on track (praise the Lord) and I realized that maybe I should give Season 2 another shot. Since I was no longer worried that Outlander was a one-season wonder, I discovered Outlander Season 2 actually has a lot going for it. Here, in no particular order are my 15 reasons to rewatch Outlander Season 2.
1.) The cold open with Claire. The first time around I wondered what the hell they were doing. Why oh why are they showing us the end at the beginning????? Rewatching means I can just enjoy Caitriona Balfe’s wonderful acting. Her face! Her crying in the road!
2.) Bear McCreary’s music: I loved how he tweaked the opening sequence with the Baroque and French music. And I had the French music on repeat on my phone for hours at a time. On some days, it’s the only thing that got me through a very toxic work environment. Put on ear buds and ignore the insanity was my go-to strategy. Anyway, the Compte’s theme! Versailles! The apothecary! I love it all.
3.) Tobias Menzies’ acting. Was there ever a moment of more acting wonder than those seconds when Claire tells him she’s pregnant and we watch his facial expressions move through misplaced initial joy to desperate recognition and frustrated anger? Tobias has been a standout since the series began and Ron D. Moore made the risky (at least potentially) choice to put one actor playing two different roles. He has nailed Black Jack Randall and Frank, cleverly showing the ways in which their genetics connects them and yet making them very different and believable men. This was the season when he could have been a serious Emmy contender. Sadly it was also the season Outlander didn’t put in nominations due to the timing of when the show was running.
4.) Murtagh: So many wonderful moments. “France. Reeks of frogs.” Fencing in the park with Jamie: “Have you never seen two men practicing the art of the sword?” “This misery of a country. I’m out of breath already. It’s the air — arses and armpits.” Reacting to learning who Claire really is. Volunteering to marry Mary. Book purists can quibble about other changes but they really should take a deep breath and simply enjoy the ways in which the TV producers have expanded Murtagh’s role. It’s wonderful to see his relationship with Jamie and really understand it in ways I don’t think the book shows as well. I, for one, can’t wait to see how he’s developed in Outlander Season 4 and beyond since we all know he’s alive.
5.) The clothes. I have loved Terry Dresbach’s costume vision for Outlander from the beginning, but this was her season to shine. Thanks to the opulence of Paris in the 18th century, we could see the breadth of her costume brain. Each outfit Claire wore was more beautiful than the last. The red dress. The nipple dress. The purple cloak. The list goes on and on. We will miss you Terry.
6.) Le Comte St. Germain: Stanley Weber was the perfect comte IMO. His complete disdain for anything and anyone not French was visible in each and every one of his perfectly coiffed moves. He makes the perfect foil. His death scene was perfect.
7.) The sets. One of the things that makes Outlander so damn good is its attention to detail, and the sets help create the standard. Simply put, Jon Gary Steele is a wizard. No wonder he created Master Raymond’s apothecary so perfectly…and the Star chamber…and Versailles. You get the idea. On a rewatch, I can revel in every glorious detail because I’m not as irritated by some of the twists and turns. (See note on #SexDroughtlander.)
8.) Duke of Sandringham. I have loved Simon Callow since I first saw him in Four Weddings and a Funeral and then Shakespeare in Love. He’s brilliant. Here he adds just the right amount of camp to this character to make the duke delightfully deceptive and delicious. And it’s so clear that he is having a good time doing it. He knows the duke has a short shelf life in the show and just plays it for all it’s worth — not unlike Bill Paterson, who plays Ned Cowan, another fave of mine.
9.) Young Fergus. Young Fergus has to grow up, so one of the perks of rewatching this season is knowing that is going to happen and, therefore, enjoying each and every Fergus moment. He brings out the mother and father in Claire and Jamie and that glimpse of their potential as parents only makes their ultimate parting all the more poignant because we have had a glimpse of what might have been. And then there’s that moment when he tells Murtagh what’s what with women. Priceless.
10.) Jamie talking to children. If we can’t see Jamie and Claire sex, Jamie talking to Claire’s belly is the next best thing, except perhaps Jamie talking to Jenny’s baby. That is all.
11.) Louise. The waxing, the friendship, the absolutely gut-wrenching scene when she helps Claire literally let go of Faith. This is lady power and friendship to the max and it only makes me appreciate my female friends more each and every time I see it. We women need to stand together.
12.) Claire’s PTSD. The first time around this annoyed me. As a book reader, I was like the what hell are you doing giving us WWII flashbacks (and at the time one reason I was saying this was because I saw this as a way for them to make room for some Jamie and Claire romance. In my defense, in case you think I’m a pervert, Dragonfly in Amber is filled with passages of them reconnecting this way. Just sayin’.) Stay on track, producers! In rewatching, though, I have realized that this was actually a smart TV move that gave depth to her character and added credence to the war scenes, generally. It provided a back story we didn’t get in the books and it was a worthy one. Apparently I don’t know as much as TV people about bringing a book series to the screen. Huh! 🙂
13.) Angus. Such a great character that really is not much of anything in the books. In the first watching of Outlander Season 2, we don’t know this is last. Book readers expect Rupert to die. So when Angus sadly, horrifyingly leaves us, it’s a shock…that we can all fix by rewatching this season with renewed appreciation for Stephen Walters and his craft.
14.) Dougal’s good-bye sequence with his brother Colum. Is there a sibling relationship anywhere that’s not complicated? Not likely and certainly not with Dougal and Colum. But this searing performance by Graham McTavish just gets better each and every time I watch it. You can feel the grief and the realization that Dougal lost his chance to ever make it right with his brother. It reminds me to say what I feel and mean to the people I love when I feel it rather than wait. Life, no matter how long, is still but a breath (to quote another favorite book of mine).
15.) Jamie and Claire good-bye dance…no words necessary.
Do you rewatch Outlander Season 2? If so, what are your favorite parts? If not, why not?
Yes bravo, Janet. I agree.
Now that I am rewatching to satisfy my Outlander fix, I think Season 2 has some gems going for it: The beauty of the costumes, sets, Murtauh, Fergus, Louise, Oh my!
Amazing acting by Cat in that first episode, and Tobias just impossible to look away!
In that one episode, they sealed their fate and future.
I thought the character of St. Germain was a antagonist that could truly be frightening.
There was a few things I did not like–too much dildos, and I think Bonny Prince Charlie was kind of a disappointment: I just couldn’t reconcile the actor playing him (or the way he was written–I don’t know) as the man that the Scots look to as their shining hope for their country.
He seemed like a prissy fop to me–something hilarious in the Duke Of Sandriam, but not what I’d expect of Bonny Prince Charlie (with someone like Dougal looking up to him)
Another thing that I would have liked to have seen, a longer season and if the Paris dynamic began right at the Versailles ball (I think it would have worked well if Claire was holding her hand out to Jamie when she was coming down the staircase in the red dress to go to the party. The exposition that they gave us wouldn’t have taken any time at all)
Does that make sense?
I agree with you about Bonny Prince Charlie. While he was fun in the way he was portrayed, I do wonder about how he could have gotten a slew of Scots to follow his leadership if he had really been like that in real life. He was over the top in a way that worked against the portrayal I think.
Thanks for reading!
You hit the high points, Janet! Also loved Jamie’s homecoming from prison and Black Jack’s appearance at Versailles.
Ah yes…those were two good ones too. 🙂
Actually, season 2 and the actors were submitted for the Emmys, they just didn’t get any nominations. Only Terry got one for season 2, and then again for season 3.
Here’s our blog post on what happened with season 2 in case you want to read it.
I agree with all these: the clothes, Tobias’s acting, the sets, all amazing. Claire and Jamie’s dance at the end was so sweet. I remember when I first saw it I was reminded of dancing with my husband. I would add another: Richard Rankin as Roger (Mackenzie) Wakefield. Though he doesn’t look like book Roger, I instantly bought him as Roger.
Yes I think Richard Rankin was a real find. The person who does the casting for this show is so good!
Your summary was spot on and captured ALL the reasons I loved season 2 from the get go…As all other seasons -I love it all. No complaints from me and I have also read the books! So glad you gave it another chance & wrote such a great review ?
Thank you. It was tough research but worth it! 🙂
As an update to what I wanted to say: I think the Paris intrigue could have began at the Versailles ball–not getting off the ship.
I think Jamie and Claire’s living in Jared’s house could have been explained in voice over giving more time to the ball. If Paris had been introduced at the ball, it could have been a nice continuation from part one with Frank, with the second half and the rest being Paris.
Maybe the St.Germain ship stuff could have been a small flashback, though his eyes and then seeing his hatred of Claire.
I’m just batting some ideas around.
Oh–and I just adored Jamie with the babies and kids. I’m a puddle on the floor just thinking about that!
I am in the process of watching all of the seasons again before Season 4 starts. I just finished watching “Prestopans” and the death of Angus. I think Stephen Walters is an amazing actor. I read all of the books before the t.v. series and, unfortunately, Angus was not a character that stood out.
It was awesome to watch Stephen make Angus Mohr come to life. He was so witty and quirky. He had me laughing so many times. But the thing that really did it for me was his mannerisms. Those facial expressions were perfect and the eyebrow raises just added even more character. He and Rupert (Grant O’Rourke) were a great team and I will miss watching them and their crazy antics.
What! I’ve watched the entire series several times. Am I ill? No, just curious, astonished and enthralled. The world wide influence Diana’s work has made in our souls should be studied in college. ?????